Frost depth refers to how deep the ground freezes during the winter months. In Ottawa, the frost depth can range from 3.5-4 feet deep. When the ground freezes, it can cause the soil to expand and push upwards, resulting in what's known as frost heave. This can cause fence posts to shift or even lift out of the ground if they are not deep enough. The force exerted by frost is tremendous and can be enough to even shift house foundations.
In addition to going deep enough, its is beneficial to “bell” out the bottom of the hole so that the concrete can resist the upward force of the frost heave.
In this example, the hole is “belled”, but the hole does not go below the frost line. In time this post would heave upwards.
What are the effects of your posts lifting up?
A weaker fence since the burial depth is being reduced as the post comes up and the concrete starts to crack.
Alignment issues, your fence lines will no longer be level, and some panels may start leaning
Broken connections as some panels lift up and others don’t.